4 stars (9)
- At Journey'S End Hotel St. Augustine
- Bayfront Marin House Bed & Breakfast St. Augustine
- Casa De Suenos B & B St. Augustine
- Casa Monica Resort & Spa, Autograph Collection St. Augustine
- Embassy Suites St Augustine Beach Oceanfront Resort St. Augustine
- Hilton Saint Augustine Historic Bayfront Hotel
- Renaissance St. Augustine Historic Downtown Hotel
- St George Inn - Saint Augustine
- The Conch House Marina Resort St. Augustine
3 stars (22)
- Bayfront Inn St. Augustine
- Bayfront Westcott House Bed & Breakfast St. Augustine
- Bella Bay Inn St. Augustine
- Best Western Historic Bayfront St. Augustine
- Best Western Historical Inn St. Augustine
- Bliss By The Sea Hotel St. Augustine
- Carriage Way Centennial House - Adult Only- Saint Augustine
- Courtyard By Marriott St. Augustine I-95 Hotel
- Edgewater Inn - St. Augustine
- Guy Harvey Resort On Saint Augustine Beach
- Hampton Inn & Suites St. Augustine-Vilano Beach
- Hampton Inn St Augustine Downtown Historic Distric St. Augustine
- Hampton Inn St Augustine Us1 North St. Augustine
- Hilton Vacation Club St Augustine Hotel St. Augustine
- Historic Sevilla House (Adults Only) St. Augustine
- Homewood Suites By Hilton St Augustine San Sebastian St. Augustine
- Magic Beach Motel - Vilano Beach, Saint Augustine
- Penny Farthing Inn St. Augustine
- Quality Inn St Augustine Historic District Area St. Augustine
- Quality Inn St Augustine Outlet Mall St. Augustine
- The Flagler Inn - Saint Augustine
- The Ponce St. Augustine Hotel
2 stars (4)
- Historic Inn - Saint Augustine
- Holiday Inn - St Augustine - World Golf By Ihg St. Augustine
- The Cozy Inn St. Augustine
- The Saint Augustine Beach House